The Ohio General Assembly not only renewed Ohio’s successful Transformational Mixed-Use District (TMUD) Program but increased the funding for the program to $250 million over the next two years. The TMUD program provides a tax credit against development costs incurred during the construction phase of a project that will be a catalyst for future development in its area. Eligible applications are divided based on location of the development, resulting in two funding groups: “major city” and “general”. The TMUD program defines a Major City as: Columbus, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Toledo, Akron, and Dayton. A Major City Project is a Project that is located either within the corporation limits of a Major City or within 10 miles of the corporation limits of a Major City. A general city project is any Project that is not located inside or within 10 miles of the corporation limits of a Major City.
ODOD is the TMUD Decider.
The General Assembly transferred responsibility for reviewing and approving TMUD applications from the Ohio Tax Credit Authority to Ohio Department of Development (ODOD) and allows the amount of previously awarded TMUD tax credits subsequently rescinded to be available for award again in the fiscal year following rescission without counting against the prescribed annual dollar limit of approved tax credits.
More TMUD awards are possible through lower award caps.
Also, the TMUD program was changed to increase the reserved amount of credits for TMUD projects located more than 10 miles from a major city from $20 million, as under current law, to 450 million plus one-third of any tax credits previously awarded but rescinded in the prior fiscal year.
Urban and rural markets have increased funding opportunities.
The Ohio General Assembly also increased the maximum amount of credits for TMUD projects within 10 miles of a major city each fiscal year from $85 million, as under current law, to $100 million plus two thirds of any tax credits previously awarded but rescinded in the prior fiscal year and any amount reserved but not awarded for projects located more than ten miles from a major city. The maximum amount of tax credit that can be awarded for a single project was reduced from $40 million to $20 million.
TMUD eligible costs expanded.
Eligible TMUD project costs to be considered when determining credit amounts now include due diligence costs and construction hard and soft costs paid in connection with the project, architectural and engineering fees and due diligence costs incurred before the project is certified by ODOD.
TMUD projects completed in phases continue to be unpopular.
The TMUD updates also eliminate the option for a portion of a project completed in phases to be considered transformational mixed-use project so long as all phases together meet the definitional requirements
Greater tax credit transferability addresses.
The Ohio General Assembly eliminated a requirement that credits be sold to raise capital for a project, allowing them to be sold for any purpose, allowed credits to be sold by insurance companies that invest in a TMUD, as opposed to current law which only allows TMUD property owners to sell credits, allowed credits to be sold more than once, eliminated a requirement that the appropriate state agency be notified when the right to claim credits is transferred or sold, expands, for credits approved after the effective date, the taxes TMUD tax credits may be claimed against to include the financial institutions tax and the income tax and eliminates a requirement that only insurance companies may claim TMUD tax credits, and permits credits approved before that date can still only be claimed against taxes on foreign and domestic insurance companies allows applications for certification as a transformational mixed use development project to identify financial institutions and other persons, apart from property owners and insurance companies, that should be awarded tax credit certificates and allows a subsequent direct award to those persons, and gives tax credit certificate holders an additional year within which to begin claiming the credits.
- Requires the Ohio Department of Development to certify information about issued TMUD tax credit certificates to the Tax Commissioner, currently information is certified only to Insurance.
- Excludes expenditures made before certification as a TMUD credit eligible project from being considered eligible expenditures upon which a tax credit may be calculated.
- Excludes any economic impact existing before certification of a project as TMUD tax credit eligible from inclusion in the required projection of increased economic impact.
- Excludes projects located in transformational major sports facility mixed-use project districts, which the bill creates, from eligibility for the transformational mixed use development tax credit.
- Includes new community authorities in the definition of “corporation” for purposes of the continuing law allowing a contract between a county and a corporation for the corporation to build and operate a sports facility funded by sales tax backed bonds.
- Provides that a new community authority is a political subdivision for purposes of a property tax exemption available for certain political-subdivision-owned sports facilities.
The Ohio General Assembly changed the TMUDs mix and number of uses required in the definition of “transformational mixed-use development” from some combination of retail, office, residential, recreation, structured parking and other similar uses to at least two uses from office, residential, hotel and hospitality, recreation, and retail, which may include restaurants. The TMUD legislative update also disqualifies a party from being considered to have contributed capital to a TMUD project without receiving anything in return, and increases projected payroll, which may be used as an alternative to a building size requirement for projects seeking TMUD credits within 10 miles of major cities, from $4 million to $5 million.
The Ohio General Assembly also enacted TMUD changes that will alter how projects are ranked and awarded funding through specific changes in the required application materials, including:
- Modifying the plans and drawings expected in a TMUD certification application.
- Requiring proposed project budgets to include an estimate of hard costs and to be organized by line item.
- Requiring viable financial plans showing at least 51% committed funding and a strategy for obtaining any remaining funding as a new application requirement.
- Requiring projected economic impact assessments to project the “direct” economic impact and be prepared by an economic impact consultant with experience performing economic impact studies in Ohio and reviewed by an independent third party reviewer retained by the Ohio Department of Development.
- Adding a standard to evaluate currently required evidence that a project will not be completed without the award of tax credits that establishes if any portion of the applicant’s project has already closed on construction financing or commenced construction, excluding brownfield remediation and demolition and thus is ineligible for a TMUD credit.
- Replaces the current considerations for ranking applications which look to return on investment, considered according to projected tax collections against tax credits, economic impact, impact on physical features, and project timelines.
- The modified ranking system utilizes a point scale based on physical scope of projects, distribution of uses across projects, government approvals, local support, committed financing, lease or purchase commitments from end users, walkability, retail and restaurant sales to be generated, payroll to be generated, and taxes to be generated.
- Requires the economic analysis completed for application ranking and credit calculation to exclude previously completed and future phases of a development and exclude consideration of any impact on the surrounding area.
- Allows persons with contracts to purchase project sites conditioned on the provisional award of a TMUD tax credit to apply for the award as if they owned the property.
- Prohibits a TMUD tax credit from being awarded in an amount greater than that applied for because of certification of actual development costs, and, under continuing law, a credit amount may be reduced after cost certification.
- Reduces the number of credit calculation methods to one, which results in a credit for property owners that is the lesser of the amount preliminarily approved or 10% of actual eligible expenditures.
- Changes the credit amount calculation method by excluding any consideration or calculation of the project’s impact beyond the project site.
- Eliminates the ability of an insurance company that contributes capital to a project to apply for a TMUD tax credit resulting in only the property owner may apply and eliminates the current law that set the credit amount for insurance companies that contribute capital to 10% of the capital contributions.
The Montrose Group has completed successful TMUD applications and economic impact statements required by the program and is glad to discuss how we can assist your project—please contact Nate Green at ngreen@montrosegroupllc.com if you have a TMUD project you are considering submitting.